Amazon’s Feedback Feature Should Be Shut Down

Introduction

Seller feedback once served a purpose… but today, it’s hanging by a thread. If you’re an Amazon FBA seller, you’ve probably noticed something strange: customers rarely leave feedback. And when they do it’s more likely to be negative. Sounds unfair, right?

Let’s break it down. Feedback was meant to reassure buyers that sellers were reliable, but with FBA (Fulfilled by Amazon), Amazon handles packaging, shipping, and returns. So why are sellers still rated for things they have no control over?

You guessed it because Amazon’s system hasn’t kept up.

And that’s why many believe the feedback feature should either be redesigned or shut down completely.

Understanding Amazon Feedback

What Is Amazon Seller Feedback?

Amazon Seller Feedback is meant to measure how reliable a seller is based on delivery, service, and communication.

Difference Between Feedback and Product Reviews

  • Feedback: Rates the seller

  • Product Reviews: Rate the product

But most customers don’t know the difference and often leave product complaints under seller feedback.

How Feedback Impacts Seller Accounts

Even one negative feedback score can:

  • Damage account health

  • Reduce Buy Box chances

  • Affect ranking

So yes… it matters.

The Decline of Fair Feedback

FBA Sellers Rarely Receive Feedback

Let’s be honest: the chance of receiving feedback is almost zero. Most customers don’t care enough to return to the order page and leave it.

Why Customers Aren’t Leaving Feedback Anymore

  • They don’t notice the request

  • They assume it’s not important

  • Product reviews seem more valuable

  • They don’t understand the system

The Overwhelming Bias Toward Negative Responses

People are more likely to complain than compliment. That means when feedback DOES appear, it’s usually negative.

Unbalanced. Unfair. Unhelpful.

Why Amazon’s Feedback System Fails

Limited Feedback Rate for FBA Orders

Studies show fewer than 1–3% of FBA orders receive feedback most of it negative.

Unfair Penalties for Negative Feedback

The system punishes sellers even when the issue was caused by Amazon’s fulfillment, not the seller.

Difficulty Removing Unfair Feedback

Getting Amazon to remove incorrect feedback is tough. Even if it’s obviously about the product not the seller appeals often fail.

Vendor vs. Third-party Limitations

Meanwhile, large Amazon vendors are barely affected, while small sellers struggle.

The FBA Factor

Amazon Fulfills the Order, Sellers Get the Blame

Amazon controls:

  • Packaging

  • Delivery

  • Customer service

Yet FBA sellers get punished for failures they cannot control.

Delivery Issues Mixed With Seller Ratings

Did a package arrive late? Damaged? Lost?
That’s Amazon’s responsibility yet the seller gets the hit. Make it make sense.

Negative Impact on Sellers

Account Health Damage

Even a single negative feedback score can drop seller rating significantly.

Loss of Buy Box

Buy Box competition is fierce and bad feedback can take you out.

Unnecessary Stress on Sellers

Why should sellers take the blame for Amazon’s mistakes? It’s exhausting.

Does Feedback Still Matter?

How Amazon Has Shifted Focus to Reviews

Product reviews are what customers look at not seller feedback.

Customer Trust Is Now Built on Product Ratings

If the product rating is good, customers buy.
Seller feedback hardly influences their decision.

Is Seller Feedback Even Useful Anymore?

Short answer? No.
Its role has faded.

Why Shutting Down Feedback May Be Better

Eliminating Bias

Good feedback almost never comes.
Negative feedback dominates. Removing this system would balance things.

Protecting Small Sellers

Small sellers suffer the most. Removing the system helps level the playing field.

Reducing Customer Confusion

Customers can focus on reviews rather than worrying about seller ratings.

Alternatives to the Current Feedback System

More Accurate Performance Metrics

Amazon could rely on:

  • Delivery data

  • Return rates

  • Customer service interactions

Automated System Based on FBA Fulfillment

If Amazon handles fulfillment, they should own the rating.

Review-Only System

Limit ratings to product quality not the seller.

Voices from the Seller Community

FBA Sellers Speak Out

Seller forums are full of complaints about feedback misuse.

Growing Demand for Feedback Removal

Many sellers believe the feature is outdated and harmful.

Potential Improvements

Transparent Appeal Process

Make feedback removal easier when it’s inaccurate.

Limit Feedback Only to FBM Sellers

If sellers ship orders themselves, feedback makes sense.

Let Buyers Rate Only Amazon Fulfillment

Simple. Fair. Logical.

Conclusion

Amazon’s seller feedback system is broken.
It’s outdated, unfair, and barely used. FBA sellers are punished for things outside their control, while customers focus almost entirely on product reviews.

Maybe it’s time to shut the feature down or at least redesign it. Because right now, it’s helping no one.

FAQs

Why don’t FBA orders get feedback?

Most customers ignore feedback requests and rarely revisit their orders to leave feedback.

How does negative feedback hurt sellers?

Negative feedback affects account health, Buy Box eligibility, and seller ranking.

Can FBA sellers remove unfair feedback?

Yes, but the process is difficult and doesn’t always work.

Are product reviews more important now?

Yes, customers rely far more on product ratings than seller feedback.

Should Amazon remove seller feedback?

Many sellers agree that the current system is unfair and should be removed or redesigned.

November 4, 2025

Leave a Reply